Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Steve Provizer's avatar

It's been a while since I read this interview, but my emotional response to it remains strong. Kofsky's bullheaded and bullying attempt to forward his own agenda really pissed me off. Kofsky kept trying to shove Coltrane into his own tiny political boxes and Trane was simply too much of a gentleman to lash out at him or walk away. He found a way to try and ameliorate the conversation. I respect the spin you're trying to put on this Bret, but Coltrane's vision was always broadly humanitarian and Kofsky's was fundamentally authoritarian and ego-driven.

Charlie Peacock's avatar

Bret, thank you for bringing this historically important interview to your audience, Substackers and beyond. I think you identified what made this interview between Kofsky and Coltrane so unique: "The conversation ultimately demonstrates how external pressures can help artists clarify their own positions and purposes." I spent significant time with Frank during his History Prof tenure at California State University at Sacramento when he was writing a Bay Area music column for The Sacramento Bee. He took an interest in me as a pianist and composer. Since I was also his student and assigned Black Nationalism and the Revolution in Music as our textbook, I attended and transcribed interviews for him as well. Most significantly, time spent with Andrew Hill, Dexter Gordon, Bobby Hutcherson, Max Roach, Eddie Henderson and many others—Andrew in his home when he lived in SF, the others backstage at Keystone Korner. I was only 19-20 at the time, so you can imagine the altitude of the cloud I was riding on. Back to the point: Frank most definitely held admiration for Black Nationalism as filtered through his own Marxism and opinions about what he considered to be authentic Black American improvisational music. He did not hold back in the prodding/steering department as you point out. I will say that Andrew Hill warned Frank not to call him a jazz musician or he'd punch him in the face. Frank may have met his match in Mr. Hill. Thank you for stirring ancient memories that still have deep meaning for me. Peace.

7 more comments...

Ready for more?